Transnational Repression: Addressing a Human Rights Protection Gap in Higher Education

By Sarah R. Creedon

Geneva Center for Business and Human Rights

In September 2026, during the 63rd session of the UN Human Rights Council, a landmark 130 UN Special Procedure mandate holders and Treaty Body members issued an unprecedented joint statement calling for coordinated international action to prevent transnational repression. This declaration demonstrates a growing multilateral consensus to close the protection gap on transnational repression.

Transnational repression (TNR)—the deliberate effort by foreign governments to intimidate, silence, coerce, or harm dissidents, human rights defenders, and diaspora members beyond their national borders—is no longer an anomaly. It can take many forms, from targeted killings to extraterritorial legislation, and has evolved into a global, systemic threat to freedom of expression, state sovereignty, and academic integrity. Freedom House has documented 1,375 direct physical incidents of transnational repression between 2015-2025, facilitated by 54 perpetrator governments across 107 countries.

Authoritarian regimes and autocratic governments increasingly weaponize cross-border surveillance, commercial spyware, cyberhacking, and law enforcement mechanisms to export repression beyond their borders. While activists across every sector may face state surveillance or physical violence in retaliation for their work, academic institutions have emerged as a particular frontline — and they are almost entirely unprepared for it.

State Obligations

TNR functions as a structural weapon of state power operating in direct violation of international law. Rights enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and in multiple conventions including Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) guarantees every individual the right to freedom of expression, to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive, and impart information regardless of frontiers. When perpetrator states deploy surveillance apparatuses, physical stalking, or rendition plots abroad, they infringe upon host-state sovereignty and breach treaty obligations.

For years, Iranian authorities tried to silence exiled journalist and activist Masih Alinejad by targeting her family who remained in Iran after she fled the country in 2009. When those tactics of repression did not stop her work from the United States, the regime brought the threat directly to her door. Over several years, state-backed operatives mapped out a brazen plot to kidnap and assassinate Alinejad at her home in Brooklyn, a conspiracy documented by the FBI, the Department of Justice, and civil society groups. While U.S. law enforcement intervened before the plan could be carried out, the case stands as a stark warning of how far foreign intelligence networks will reach across international borders to try to silence their critics.

Global Momentum and the UN Framework

The international community is increasingly recognizing the urgent need for structural remedies to safeguard civil society from extraterritorial threats. At the UN Human Rights Council in September 2026, human rights advocates—such as Hong Kong democracy advocate Anna Kwok—delivered powerful interventions exposing the mechanics of extraterritorial coercion and demanding concrete protective mechanisms for targeted human rights defenders. This advocacy mirrors broader multilateral progress in discussing the topic of TNR, including through numerous joint statements, UN special procedure reports, and UN resolutions such as HRC 58/23 on protecting human rights defenders in the digital age. The Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), civil society organizations like the International Service for Human Rights (ISHR), and UN member states have repeatedly emphasized that governments bear a positive obligation under international law to protect all individuals within their jurisdiction from foreign interference and harm.

The Campus Frontline: Academic Freedom under Siege

Universities are built on open inquiry and uninhibited debate, yet overseas students, faculty, and visiting researchers increasingly face targeted intimidation designed to chill speech on host-country campuses. Reporting by Amnesty International and Freedom House documents a widespread pattern where foreign state or state-aligned actors use methods such as monitoring peaceful campus demonstrations, pressuring scholars abroad by threatening relatives in home countries, and directly lobbying university administrators to restrict research or cancel events critical of foreign state policies. When students and scholars are forced into self-censorship out of fear for their safety or their families’ security, the core integrity of higher education is threatened.

This practice has impacted a wide range of countries including Australia, where Human Rights Watch documented widespread self-censorship among Chinese pro-democracy students, leading Australian academics to pioneer recommendations for anonymous grading and secure research channels. In Canada, Amnesty International’s investigation revealed systematic coercion and surveillance targeting diaspora students across Canadian universities, exposed further by Canada’s Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference. In the UK, where they have adopted TNR policies, the majority of TNR student victims are human rights activists, according to the University of Bristol’s comprehensive study. In the European Union, the Council of Europe referred to TNR as a primary “blind spot” in European academic freedom frameworks. In Switzerland, studies commissioned by the Federal Council and conducted via the University of Basel documented persistent surveillance against Tibetan and Uyghur scholars, revealing that Swiss universities currently rely on generic criminal code provisions (e.g., Swiss Criminal Code Art. 271) rather than dedicated institutional support structures.

In the United States, students and academic community members have been photographed and recorded for participating in prodemocracy protests in solidarity with protests in a foreign country and family member in the origin country of the protestors have been harassed and discouraged to study overseas. Freedom House reports that the biggest threat to international students and scholars studying and working in the United States is the government of China, followed by Egypt, India, Rwanda, and Saudi Arabia.

Protection Responsibilities

To close this protection gap, universities cannot treat TNR as a routine interpersonal dispute or rely solely on state intelligence agencies. Higher education leadership must operationalize comprehensive TNR prevention policies.

For higher education administrators, turning policy into institutional protection requires implementing models already emerging in the United States. The University of Wisconsin Madison’s International Safety and Security office addresses transitional repression as a key risk area. The University of North Texas provides an information sheet with a clear definition of TNR, tactics, warning signs, and resources. Kansas State University established a dedicated Transnational Repression Resources and Complaint Procedure (PPM Chapter 3014), designating campus safety and legal liaisons specifically trained in state-backed coercion. Similarly, the Utah System of Higher Education (Policy R267 / H.B. 547) mandated that all 16 public campuses provide dedicated educational resources and confidential reporting pipelines for international students and faculty facing extraterritorial threats.

How Can Universities Protect Their Institution and Their Students from Transnational Repression?

To effectively counter transnational repression, universities must establish a policy framework that recognizes TNR as a distinct human rights, academic freedom, and protection challenge. Institutional policies should be directly informed by civil society research and UN human rights standards. To create a safe and enabling academic environment, university leadership must institute proactive measures that bridge faculty training, internal reporting protocols, protection measues, and IT governance.

First, universities must build institutional capacity by delivering specialized training for faculty, administrative leadership, student affairs, and offices of general counsel to recognize the distinct patterns of TNR—ranging from proxy intimidation and digital tracking to overt pressure from foreign officials. Training should include reviewing real world scenarios and early warning signs such as receiving direct communication from country representatives who frequently carry out TNR. Faculty and university staff should be familiar with common techniques of surveillance, such as recording at campus events, lectures, or protests by state and non-state actors coerced to carry out TNR on behalf of a state. Human rights centers should be particularly attuned to the enhanced vulnerability of scholars from countries who repress freedom of expression.

Second, institutions should establish confidential, dedicated reporting mechanisms that allow targeted scholars to report incidents safely. Establish urgent action plans, including protocols for senior administration officials to engage with relevant law enforcement agencies immediately in the event real-world harm appears immediate. When coordinating with local or national law enforcement, universities must enforce victim-centered protocols to prioritize safety.

Third, university leadership should publish TNR policies and issue explicit, public commitments against TNR as an integral component of institutional academic freedom and freedom of expression. Silence in response to TNR threats only emboldens the authoritarian and autocratic regimes employing those tactics thereby enhancing the vulnerability of the victim and institution as a whole.

Fourth, universities must protect their digital ecosystem. Campus communications and data infrastructure must be shielded from malign influence. Universities should audit IT procurement through a robust human rights due diligence framework. Universities must ensure that software vendors, virtual learning platforms, and institutional databases adhere to strict data protection standards that prevent unauthorized cross-border data transfers or commercial spyware exploitation. Cyber security protocols should be in place to thwart digital surveillance, harassment and online intimidation, targeted hacking, spyware installation, phishing attempts, or online smear campaigns.

In summary academic institutions should:

  1. Train: Build Faculty Awareness o Raise awareness about TNR through the department deans, cover the definition and common tactics. o Train faculty to spot early warning signs and follow reporting protocols.

  2. Report: Establish Safe Channels o Create clear confidential reporting channels for victims. o Implement a rapid response protocol to intervene immediately when cases emerge.

  3. Speak: Commit Publicly o Publish and enforce a public commitment to address TNR. o Publicly denounce instances of TNR when they occur.

  4. Protect: Provide a Secure Digital and Physical Environment o Harden the digital ecosystem to thwart digital surveillance and online harassment. o Provide physical protection for targeted individuals.

Protecting academic freedom from state-sponsored coercion requires an unyielding, coordinated commitment grounded in human rights. Crossing international borders to pursue higher education or advocate for human rights should guarantee protection, not extend vulnerability.

Resources

● International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR): Article 19 & General Comment No. 34 UN Human Rights Committee. o https://www.ohchr.org/en/treaty-bodies/ccpr/background-international-covenant-civil-and-political-rights-and-optional-protocols

● Joint Call by UN Human Rights Experts: Over 130 UN Experts Call for Global Action to End Transnational Repression (UN OHCHR September 2026). o https://www.ohchr.org/en/statements-and-speeches/2026/09/joint-statement-united-nations-human-rights-experts-transnational

● Freedom House: Addressing Transnational Repression on Campuses in the United States (2024). o https://freedomhouse.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/TNR_UniversityReport_2024F.pdf

● Amnesty International: On My Campus I Am Afraid - China’s Targeting of Overseas Students Stifles Rights (2024).“On my campus I am Afraid: China’s Targeting of Overseas Students Stifles Rights”

● Amnesty International Canada: Surveillance, Censorship and Harassment of Chinese International Students in Canada. (2024) o https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/05/china-overseas-students-face-harassment-and-surveillance-in-campaign-of-transnational-repression/

● Human Rights Watch: Code of Conduct for Responding to Threats to Academic Freedom (2019). o Code of Conduct for Responding to Threats to Academic Freedom (PRC) https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/supporting_resources/190321_china_academic_freedom_coc_0.pdf

● Council of Europe: Transnational Repression and Threats to Scholars (Academic Freedom Insights Series). (2025) o https://www.coe.int/en/web/education/-/transnational-repression-and-threats-to-scholars

● International Service for Human Rights (ISHR): Transnational Repression — Advancing UN and Regional Frameworks Despite Protection Gaps o Human Rights Council Reprisals Debate & TNR Trends https://ishr.ch/latest-updates/human-rights-council-reprisals-debate-highlights-growing-trend-of-transnational-repression/

● OHCHR Guidance: Tools and Resources on Transnational Repression https://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/tools-and-resources/transnational-repression

● University of Wisconsin-Madison, International Safety and Security. Undue Influence and Transnational Repression. o https://internationaltravel.wisc.edu/before-you-go/

● Kansas State University: Policy and Procedures Manual, Chapter 3014: Transnational Repression Resources and Complaint Procedure. o https://www.k-state.edu/policies/ppm/3000/3014.html

● Utah System of Higher Education: Policy R267 / House Bill 547: Educational Resources and Reporting Pipelines for Transnational Repression. o https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0547.html

● University of North Texas: https://research.unt.edu/support-units/research-integrity-and-compliance/transnational-repression.pdf

● UK: Guidance on protecting higher education from foreign interference, February 2026 https://www.gov.uk/guidance/protecting-uk-higher-education-from-foreign-interference

● European Parliament: TNR Mapping Trends and Improving Responses https://www.europarl.europa.eu/committees/en/transnational-repression-mapping-trends-/product-details/20251126EOT09021

● HRC Interventions and Joint Statements: o Statement by Anna Kwok at the UN Human Rights Council https://youtu.be/6wEEke5ZuX8?is=QW3gZEfvVW9NhrzC o 2025: Joint statement read by Germany https://www.norway.no/en/missions/wto-un/nig/statements/hr/hrc/hrc60/hrc60item3gd/

● FBI: Transnational Repression Resource Page & Reporting Guidelines https://www.fbi.gov/investigate/counterintelligence/transnational-repression

● Department of Justice: Recent cases of TNR in U.S. https://www.justice.gov/nsd/transnational-repression-tnr